Current Flavours
Afternoon Delight
A cookie that feels like home. Take a pause and revel in a chewy oatmeal cookie inspired by after school snacks and carefree days, crowned with an unforgettable sugar pie filling. Warm, nostalgic, and deeply comforting, it’s the kind of love that shows up quietly
THE CELEBRATION
The iconic celebration cookie in all its rainbow glory. Indulge with this cookie-shaped nod to birthday cake. Cake crumb flourishes. Classic Vanilla Frosting and topped with birthday cake crumb.
Strawberry Shortcake
Strawberry shortcake in cookie form. Bursting with strawberry flavour, folded with strawberry flakes, creamy white chocolate, and chunks of golden cookies & cream for that perfect soft-meets-crunch bite.
Classic Peanut Butta
A true classic, just like you remember. Soft, rich, and packed with that unmistakable peanut butter flavour, finished with the signature crisscross top. No extras, no fuss, just pure comfort in every bite. The kind of cookie that takes you straight back to childhood.
Coffee Cake
In honour of Debbie and the heart of Hudson Traders, this cinnamon coffee cookie brings a soft sour cream tang and a classic streusel topping, inspired by slow mornings and small-town life and perhaps a nod to then Gilmore Girls…
Milk Chocolate
Milk chocolate chips melt into every bite of this classic cookie. A sweet reminder of A classic love story. Familiar, comforting, and impossible to outgrow.
Ry’s Fave
Rich chocolate cookie loaded with cookies & cream crumb, topped with an Oreo-inspired icing and finished with a generous cookie crumble. Made for Ryan. Because his favourite has always been cookies & cream, and he makes every day a little sweeter.
CUSTOM ORDER?
We happily take custom orders from off menu flavours to cookies made for your next celebration, gathering, or meaningful moment. Reach out anytime to start the conversation to alexandra@mybrothersbakery.ca