CUSTOM ORDER?
We happily take custom orders from off menu flavours to cookies made for your next celebration, gathering, or meaningful moment. Reach out anytime to start the conversation to alexandra@mybrothersbakery.ca
Current Flavours
Chocolate Fudge Sunday
The ultimate taste of childhood summer. A rich chocolate cookie piled high with vanilla buttercream, silky chocolate fudge, rainbow sprinkles, and a cherry on top, just like your favourite ice cream sundae after a long day in the sun.
Blueberry White Chocolate
Inspired by our summer along the coast of Maine, where blueberry season is in full bloom and every roadside stand feels like a hidden gem. Bursting with juicy blueberries, bright lemon, and creamy white chocolate, this cookie captures the fresh, sun-soaked flavours of salty sea air, winding coastal roads, and the sweetest days of summer.
The Honey
.This cornbread cookie has a sweet but salty base , with a swirl of honey buttercream. Inspired by first loves and forever sweethearts, it’s comforting, nostalgic, and quietly unforgettable.
Mint Chip
Inspired by classic mint chocolate chip ice cream; a soft buttery mint cookie loaded with pools of rich chocolate chips for the ultimate cool and creamy combo. Refreshing, light and basically summer in a cookie!
Lemon Cheesecake
Our Lemon Cheesecake Cookie starts with a soft lemon sugar cookie stuffed with a creamy citrus foreward cheesecake filling. Finished with a drizzle of white chocolate and fresh lemon zest for the perfect balance of sweet and tangy in every bite.
Churro
Our Churro Cookie is inspired by the classic carnival favourite. A cinnamon cookie baked to a dense chew with a slight crisp, finished with a cinnamon vanilla glaze that melts into every swirl. Sweet, warm, and reminiscent of fresh churros from the midway.
Peanut Butter Crunch Bar
Inspired by the chocolate bars we'd pick up from the local dépanneur, this peanut butter cookie is packed with hearty oats for the perfect crunch and finished with a rich, dense layer of chocolate icing. A nostalgic bite that brings back the simple joy of your favourite after-school treat.
Orange Creamsicle
A summer favourite reimagined as a cookie. Soft vanilla-orange dough baked to a dense bakery-style chew, filled with bright citrus flavour and finished with a creamy white chocolate glaze. Inspired by the classic creamsicle ice cream truck treat. sweet, creamy, citrusy, and impossible to have just one.
Afternoon Delight
A cookie that feels like home. Take a pause and revel in a chewy oatmeal cookie inspired by after school snacks and carefree days, crowned with an unforgettable sugar pie filling. Warm, nostalgic, and deeply comforting, it’s the kind of love that shows up quietly
Butter Pecan
This butter pecan cookie begins with a nutty brown butter, folded with rich dark chocolate and finished with salted pecans. Warm, layered, and indulgent, its inspired by the loves that grow deeper with time.
Apple Pie
Inspired by a buttery pie crust, each cookie is filled with a warm apple pie filling, then rolled in a nostalgic blend of sugar and cozy spices for the perfect finishing touch. Sweet, comforting, and full of homemade charm, it's the kind of cookie that tastes like crisp autumn afternoons, family gatherings, and fresh pie cooling on the counter.
Morning Stack
A pancake inspired cookie, topped with a drizzle of maple buttermilk glaze and a perfect dollop of vanilla buttercream; like Sunday brunch in cookie form!
Cereal Crunch
Inspired by lazy mornings, cartoons on TV, and a bowl of your favourite cereal at the kitchen table. This playful cookie is packed with crunchy cornflakes, gooey marshmallows, and pools of milk chocolate throughout. A Summer kind of breakfast.
No spoon required.
Strawberry Crisp
A soft brown butter oat cookie stuffed with sweet strawberry preserves, finished with a strawberry glaze and a buttery oat crumble. Inspired by warm strawberry crumble fresh from the oven, sweet, nostalgic, and bursting with summer in every bite.
Milk Chocolate
Milk chocolate chips melt into every bite of this classic cookie. A sweet reminder of A classic love story. Familiar, comforting, and impossible to outgrow.
Apple Fritter
A cookie that feels like home. Take a pause and revel in a chewy oatmeal cookie inspired by after school snacks and carefree days, crowned with an unforgettable sugar pie filling. Warm, nostalgic, and deeply comforting, it’s the kind of love that shows up quietly
Pumpkin Spice
Our iconic Pumpkin Spice Cookie is the taste of fall in every bite. Made with real pumpkin, warm autumn spices, and topped with our signature cream cheese frosting, it's soft, cozy, and the cookie our customers wait for all year.
THE CELEBRATION
The iconic celebration cookie in all its rainbow glory. Indulge with this cookie-shaped nod to birthday cake. Cake crumb flourishes. Classic Vanilla Frosting and topped with birthday cake crumb.
Chocolate Chip
Our Semi-Sweet Chocolate Chip Cookie is a timeless classic. Soft, buttery, and loaded with rich semi-sweet chocolate chips, it's perfectly balanced, endlessly comforting, and baked to satisfy every chocolate lover.